English Constitution Walter Bagehot Books
Download As PDF : English Constitution Walter Bagehot Books
This book was originally published prior to 1923, and represents a reproduction of an important historical work, maintaining the same format as the original work. While some publishers have opted to apply OCR (optical character recognition) technology to the process, we believe this leads to sub-optimal results (frequent typographical errors, strange characters and confusing formatting) and does not adequately preserve the historical character of the original artifact. We believe this work is culturally important in its original archival form. While we strive to adequately clean and digitally enhance the original work, there are occasionally instances where imperfections such as blurred or missing pages, poor pictures or errant marks may have been introduced due to either the quality of the original work or the scanning process itself. Despite these occasional imperfections, we have brought it back into print as part of our ongoing global book preservation commitment, providing customers with access to the best possible historical reprints. We appreciate your understanding of these occasional imperfections, and sincerely hope you enjoy seeing the book in a format as close as possible to that intended by the original publisher.
English Constitution Walter Bagehot Books
This is a fantastic collection of essays written by one of the foremost scholars on the English constitution in modern history. Bagehot can be difficult to read and follow along to, but having immense interest in British politics and the institutions of Crown and Government, how they work together and serve purpose to one another this is a very interesting book to have. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in studying such institutions.Product details
|
Tags : English Constitution [Walter Bagehot] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. This book was originally published prior to 1923, and represents a reproduction of an important historical work,Walter Bagehot,English Constitution,Ulan Press,B009N74F1G,HISTORY General
People also read other books :
- 2012 Deadly Awakening edition by Beryl Gorbman Mystery Thriller Suspense eBooks
- Above and Beyond edition by Jim Morris Literature Fiction eBooks
- The Pearl Trilogy Arianne Richmonde Books
- Denmark M Pearson Thomson Books
- Hands Full of Ashes eBook Kim Hotzon
English Constitution Walter Bagehot Books Reviews
This book stimulates the little gray cells. Every time I watch Prime Minister's Questions, the superiority of the Cabinet system over the Presidential system is painfully obvious. If Bush were subjected to the kind of scrutiny, in Congress, that Blair is subjected to every week in Parliament, he would have been exposed as an impostor long before supreme executive authority was placed in his hands. Refering to our Civil War, Bagehot wrote "The notion of employing a man of unknown smallness at a crisis of unknown greatness is to our minds simply ludicrous. Mr. Lincoln, it is true, happened to be a man of... eminent justness... But success in a lottery is no argument for lotteries."
Well, we used up all of our good fortune in the 1860s. We've come up craps in this millenium.
First, to the reviewer looking for the doctrine of separation of powers you'll find it in Montequieu's "Spirit of the Laws". Also check out "The Federalist", number 51.
Now then, Bagehot, like Madison, describes the operation of a modern liberal regime. The trick for founders of liberal government is to produce a government that permits the people civil liberties, but does not permit the people to abuse those liberties, or in the words of Madison, to create a government that is "democratic yet decent". Madison and the American Founders accomplish this end by so constructing the institutions of government that mens' selfish natures will be turned against each other ("ambition is made to check ambition"), rather than united in tyrannical concert.
Bagehot too describes the operation of a system of government that rules by the consent of the governed, yet which does so by restraining the vices of those who ought not to rule. Bagehot argues that the English government is moderate and decent because of a division of government into the "dignified" and the "efficient" parts, and a "noble lie" about the relationship between the two. It is this noble lie that permits the government to operate without the interference of those who would turn it away from the public good. But to discover the noble lie, you'll have to read Bagehot.
Warner Winborne
Professor of Political Science
Hampden-Sydney College
Hampden-Sydney, VA
Walter Bagehot was a journalist and a social and political thinker of the middle Victorian period (1850s and 1860s). His classical work "The English Constitution" comes as a collection of polemical assays upon the structure of the British political system. Cabinet, monarchy, Houses of Commons and Lords, execution of political power, and the foundation of the systems of checks and balances are explored in the book.
Throughout the book a comparison and contrast of Cabinet system and the Presidential system (a.k.a USA) is a constant theme. Bagehot does not hide it preference for the Cabinet system, which in his view is a both more dynamic and more effective. One of his main points is that direct popular election is a myth, since most of the electorate are ignorant of the nature of the political power (and moreover are forced to this ignorance by the effective uselessness of the legislative debate in the USA as opposed to the UK). Moreover, a result of the direct election is a static Presidential term of 4 years, which allows the executive branch to execute almost unchecked control of the political process. According to Bagehot, the indirect electoral system of the Commons, where people vote for the MPs and they then select the PM amongst themselves produces a more effective government, which is more responsive to the popular will since it can fall at any time due to policy disputes. A hidden secret of British success according to Bagehot is a fusion of legislative and executive powers in the Cabinet system. In the latter chapters, Bagehot exposures two forms of power - the dignified power (in the person of the monarch and the lords) and the effective power as exemplified by the Cabinet. Dignified power serves as a façade of legitimacy under which the dynamic and opportunist real effective power can subsist. He follows through to explain how each of the minister of the government exercises its power for the common goal, what are the legal powers of the monarchy and how it is exercised indirectly via control of the composition of the peerage and the power to dissolve the Commons.
Bagehot's style is clear, flavorful, his knowledge of political process is profound (with a qualification of more so of British then American), his research is well done, and he is a master of dramatic tricks to keep the reader interested. I would recommend the book as both a scholarly reference, and a well presented popular case.
I thought this would actually be a source for the English Constitution. Instead it is a rambling essay on the changes between 2 decades at the end of the 19th century. It is totally worthless for my purpose.
Still arguably the leading exposition of the traditions, common law, historical Parliamentary acts, concessions of the crown (most famously, Magna Carta), and usages that comprise the nation's unwritten "constitution," as England uses that term. The writing seems stilted by modern standards and the journalistic approach overly respectful of ruling class sensibilities, perhaps, again by modern standards. But a foundational work and an ambitious one in its day all the same. I rate it highly not because it is great literature or even great scholarship, but because I think it endures as important in this area.
This is a fantastic collection of essays written by one of the foremost scholars on the English constitution in modern history. Bagehot can be difficult to read and follow along to, but having immense interest in British politics and the institutions of Crown and Government, how they work together and serve purpose to one another this is a very interesting book to have. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in studying such institutions.
0 Response to "[ITZ]⇒ Read Gratis English Constitution Walter Bagehot Books"
Post a Comment